Everyone is kind of weird you can subscribe to the podcast at itunes or elsewhere, get the rss feed, or listen via the media player above. Us pollster nate silver on uk and us election results bbc news. Why so many predictions fail but some dont is a 2012 book by nate silver detailing the art of using probability and statistics as applied to realworld circumstances. It was the first general election at the end of a fixedterm parliament. Why most predictions fail but some dont alternatively stylized as the signal and the noise. Statistician nate silver predicts conservatives as largest party but an incredibly messy outcome. He is currently the editorinchief of espns fivethirtyeight blog and a special correspondent for abc news. Conservatives shock the world but not me in uk election. Nathaniel read silver born january, 1978 is an american statistician and writer who analyzes baseball see sabermetrics and elections see psephology.
Nate silver a math genius and celebrated baseball statistician whose uncannily accurate presidential election forecasts have shaken up the world of political polling. The reason for the shock, of course, is that polls had labour either winning or, at the very least, fighting the conservatives down to the last seat. Its 59 days until the vote on may 7 and were just a few short weeks away from the start of the short campaign. Jul 09, 2014 collateral damage of germanys humiliation of brazil could be nate silver s reputation as a predictor of events. Statistician nate silver attempts to predict the outcome of the general election. Nothing is more common than for someone like silvera media phenom with a strong platform his 538 blog to create a book to cash in on his 15 minutes. On the morning of 7 may 2015, the day of the uk general election, it looked like the country was heading for a hung parliament. Known as a superstar statistician whose blog gave democrats daily data that calmed them down last fall, silver was the keynote speaker at. The signal and the noise and millions of other books are available for instant access.
A small triumph for markets and maths nov 7th 2012, 12. Nate silver, the statistician who correctly predicted the results in every state in the 2012 us election, has suggested there could be an incredibly messy outcome to the uk general election. Statistician nate silver tells panorama reporter richard bacon about his prediction for the general election. Lets bring in the liberal democrats and see how that affected the results. One was a couple of weeks ago on male suicide and the other was this tuesdays episode about nate silver attempting to predict the outcome of the forthcoming general election here in the uk. Throughout the early 2000s american ratings agencies like moodys used housing data from the 1980s and 1990s, when house prices barely budged, to predict the likelihood of houses defaulting. Whoever wins the most seats, itll be a mess, says superstar pollster nate silver who correctly called 99 out of 100 states in the us elections is having a little.
I wont pretend to be an expert on uk politics and even less on uk polling. Ive interviewed one of the heroes of last years us elections forecasting expect nate silver for the books blog, but i thought coffeehousers might be interested in what he had to say. Nate silver uk general election forecast 2015 as wrong as. Fivethirtyeight politics fivethirtyeight, 538, espn. Apr 27, 2015 the american statistician nate silver has given his prediction for the uk general election. Us pollster nate silver on uk and us election results.
Like the housing crisis, the rise of the snp is an outofsample event. Nate silver is making this up as he goes common dreams views. Nate silver grabbed the headlines last year when he correctly predicted the outcome of the us presidential election in all 50 states when other commentators were expecting a dead heat. Our final forecast was for the conservatives to win. Silver is the face of the data reporting, which had been seen as one of the only growth sectors in journalism. Nothing that i learned changed my forecast of the u. If you look at the signal and the noise, one of the themes is that, in general, consensus predictions are more accurate than. Nate silver, the statistician who correctly predicted the results in every.
Us statistical genius nate silver got uk 2010 election. Nate silver said the polls were most likely to give a clear idea. He was named one of times 100 most influential people in the world, and one of rolling stones top agents of change. It is difficult to describe this graph as anything other than mass carnage for the forecasters. The predictions were off, and not by a small amount. However, its worth remembering that with the 2010 general election in the uk, silver didnt do quite so well in the run up to election day, silver anticipated heavy losses for labour, and big gains for the. No calculations are necessary to see that we missed badly in our forecast of the u. May 08, 2015 whenever that election arrives, well aim to be ready with better forecasts than we had in 2015. In his preelection forecast, he forecast 278 seats for conservatives and 267 for labour. Bbc world news panorama, who will win the election. Nate silver leaves the new york times to join espn. The 2015 uk general election reminds of of this fact. Man who correctly predicted each state in 2012 us election tips tories to take most seats, but says threeparty coalition is most likely result. Transcript for nate silver on fivethirtyeights election day forecast money and more on where the race stands right now.
The 2015 united kingdom general election was held on thursday, 7 may 2015 to elect 650 members to the house of commons. Local elections took place in most areas on the same day polls and commentators had predicted the outcome would be too close to call and would result in a second consecutive hung parliament that would. It examines what leads people to get predictions wrong, and what leads people to get them rightlike silver did when. Nathaniel read nate silver born january, 1978 is an american statistician and writer who analyzes baseball and elections. Ben lauderdale is an associate professor of social research methods at the london school of. Nate silver tries to separate his moderately libertarian personal views from his desire to make sense of often contradictory polls. Yes, he called the us general election correctly but he then led the fashionable view that opinion polling technology is now so advanced as to be able to. If youre not familiar with the broad storyline, it goes something like this. As much as we try to remind you all about how uncertain elections can be pleas that sometimes fall on deaf ears its important to keep in. Ahead of the curve leigh american academy of actuaries. Electionoracle uk general election may 04, 2015 03.
Nate silver mostly puts his finger on what happened. Fivethirtyeight is publishing forecasts for the 2015 parliamentary election developed by chris hanretty, ben lauderdale and nick vivyan. He said it was easier to predict us elections than uk ones as america. Nate comes out of the world of baseball statistics, but during. More information, more problemsthis book was recommended by one the many books related emails i get each day. Prediction is a really important tool, its not a game nate silver made a name for himself with his uncannily accurate predictions of baseball scores and us election results. Nate silver s book, the signal and the noise, is about making predictions. Statistician nate silver tells panorama reporter richard bacon about his prediction. Tories will win most seats but outcome will be messy. The past few days have seen whats likely to be the biggest moment of levity in the entire 2015 general election and if you think this thing has been dragging on, spare a thought for me and my fellow americans, eightyone weeks from our next general election and currently wading through hundreds of thinkpieces about the existential significance of hillary clintons order at a mexican fast. Apr 23, 2015 our latest freakonomics radio episode is called nate silver says. In his pre election forecast, he gave 278 seats to conservatives and 267 to labour.
Fivethirtyeight politics fivethirtyeight, 538, espn, nate. Apr 28, 2015 28 apr 2015 american pollster and statistician nate silver has admitted he has no idea who will be in power after the general election. Shortly after midnight there, he was forecasting 272. His ambitious new book, the signal and the noise, is a practical handbook and a philosophical manifesto in one, following the theme of prediction through a series of case studies ranging from hurricane tracking to professional poker to counterterrorism. The announcement came as a surprise and was widely believed to be motivated by the large lead in the polls approximately twenty points that ms may holds over her main rival, labour party leader jeremy corbyn. Silvers mothers family, of english and german descent, includes several distinguished men and women, including his maternal greatgrandfather, harmon lewis, who was president of the. Us statistician nate silver predicts conservatives will win most seats but enormous uncertainty over formation of final.
Data guru nate silver of tells nprs scott simon how all the forecasts, including his own, were so far off in predicting the results of this weeks british election. The signal and the noise by nate silver is a 2012 penguin publication. Nate silver is a statistician and political forecaster at the new york times. After this election, the threat to it may go well beyond one site. But far more often, as i describe in the book, experts are too confident in their. Nathaniel read silver born january, 1978 is an american statistician and writer who. Well, first of all, most of nate silver s work has been devoted to american politics, yet uk elections are a totally different beast. Having said all that, a world with silver in public life is better than a world in which he sits quietly at home making money.
This is exactly the issue general election forecasters in the uk now face. His party ended with an overall majority of 12 in the 650seat house of. From the number of parties to the political system itself, many of the lessons learned in the us could not or should not be applied in british. Silvers prediction is based on historical patterns, solid data, and sound reasoning.
Election forecasting guru nate silvers forecasting firm, that got the 2015 uk general election just as badly wrong as he the previous 2010, have been busy putting. Its 59 days until the vote on may 7 and were just a few short weeks away from the start of the short camp. Nate silver has been called a spreadsheet psychic and numbercrunching prodigy by. Nate silver badly wrong again on uk general election forecast. The signal and the noise nate silver we conclude our trilogy of influential betting books, with another tome that isnt solely about betting, yet provides valuable insight into a skill which is essential for successful betting predictive ability. Nate silver s book the signal and the noise, on the uses of statistical methods for prediction, is one of my favourite books of recent years and is. Nate silver visited the uk before the election to opine on the election explained to the british public, what we know is that its highly likely you wont have a majority. Nate silver blew it bigly on the election can his brand. Nate silvers book, the signal and the noise, is about making predictions. You can also read the transcript, which includes credits for the music youll hear in the episode. In the aftermath of the us presidential election, polling guru nate silver has been enjoying widespread plaudits having called the outcome in each of the fifty states correctly. To the surprise of almost every commentator and most other politicians, david cameron led the conservative party to outright victory in the u.
Three must read books for bettors betting strategy. A good book from excellent author and uncannilysuccessful political predictor nate silver in great need of an editor. Apr 28, 2015 news uk uk politics general election 2015 general election 2015. Six things i learned while traveling the united kingdom in an airstream trailer. Nate silver blames polls for poor forecast may 8, 2015 at 7. The uk election 2015 explained for nonbrits general. Labour faces wipeout at hands of snp and ukip will have just one mp nate silver, the worlds most respected pollster, says that the tories will win the. Nate silver serves as a sort of zen master to american electionwatchers. Nate silver on predicting the 2015 general election the. Shortly after midnight, he was forecasting 272 seats for. On monday nate silver waded into the uk election by partnering with election forecast, after creating his own fairly inaccurate model in 2010. It is a commercial venture that has to maintain reader interest and distinguish itself from the competition. Statistician nate silver says clinton is a 2 to 1 favorite to win silvers model successfully predicted all 50 states in the 2012 election.
Uk general election may 7th 2015 the official election. In his preelection forecast, he gave 278 seats to conservatives and 267 to labour. Appearing on bbc ones panorama show last night, silver there was enormous uncertainty over the outcome of the uk election and that no party is anywhere near the 326 seats needed for a majority. With so many uk political parties in the frame, the bbcs panorama programme invited us superstatistician, nate silver, to answer the burning question. On 18th april 2017 theresa may announced a snap general election to take place on 8th june.
The difference between the united kingdom, great britain and england explained duration. Nate silvers failure as celebrated as brazils collapse. In calling the snap election at this point, theresa may has put a lot of confidence in her. The signal and the noise nate silver 9780143125082. Sturgeon says tories bullied miliband into rejecting snp support. May 08, 2015 nate silver blames polls for poor forecast may 8, 2015 at 7. He has written an extremely good book when he didnt even have to. Silvers book, the signal and the noise, was published in september 2012. From the stock market to the poker table, from earthquakes to the economy, he takes us on an enthralling insiders. Nate silvers fivethirtyeight uses statistical analysis hard numbers to tell compelling stories about elections, politics, sports, science, economics and. Latest news and results for the general election 2015. Nate silver fared terribly in thursdays uk election.
Nate silver on fivethirtyeights election day forecast. With a text 500pp long without back matter, but still rather factual and straightforward unlike the guilty pleasure purple prose of taleb or stephenson its very repetitive. Sep 27, 2012 one of the more momentous books of the decade. For the american football player, see nate silver quarterback. Nate silver s election forecast jump to media player statistician nate silver tells panorama reporter richard bacon about his prediction for the general election. Nate silver has done an incredible and, quite possibly an unpredictable thing with the signal and the noise. In 2012, he correctly predicted the outcome of 50 out of 50 states during the us presidential election, trumping the professional pollsters and pundits. In the signal and the noise, the new york times political forecaster nate silver, who accurately predicted the results of every state in the 2012 us election, reveals how we can all develop better foresight in an uncertain world. Nate silver and the fivethirtyeight team cover the latest in politics, tracking the issues and gamechangers every week. He is also now responsible for the 538 staff, whose livelihood depends on the success of 538. Nate silver is considered by many as the posterboy for prediction markets.
As figure 1 shows, there is no obvious best or worse poll, which supports the concept of herding described by nate silver, editor. The rise of the snp is a phenomenon without precedent. He is the founder and editorinchief of fivethirtyeight and a special. Truth be told, far too many politicians and reporters treat pollsters like soothsayers these days. Nate silver is probably under severe pressures in running the present version of 538. It will be a supremely valuable resource for anyone who wants to make good guesses about the future, or who wants to assess the guesses made by others. His site fivethirtyeight will soon start making authoritative statements on scotland, but silver once highlighted the problem we are all facing in this election. Sure, it does seem possible to anticipate us elections, but this may say something about american exceptionalism e.
In subsequent years, he and his organization, fivethirtyeight, have produced inconsistent results. Nate silver uk general election forecast 2015 as wrong as 2010. But in the wake of the disastrous performance of pollsters in the uk predicting the outcome of the general election there, i think its worth reflecting on the lessons to be learned. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. I cant remember what the particular theme was for its recommendation, although im sure it had something to do with how political forecasting data could fail so. Why so many predictions failbut some dont by silver, nate and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at. Nate silver economist world news, politics, economics. May 05, 2015 nate silver visited the uk before the election to opine on the election explained to the british public, what we know is that its highly likely you wont have a majority. And no pollster cultivates this treatment more than nate silver whose fivethirtyeight analytics attained. The book includes case studies from baseball, elections, climate change, the 2008 financial crash.
480 627 92 30 1457 128 646 1008 821 355 1256 371 426 1453 1452 1293 291 673 1373 403 1557 482 263 1166 78 1080 895 1276 1245 1120 1289 730 228 321 717 938 60 1040 671 914 474 1486 1303 576 419 685